Furious Love Island fans have suspected Teddy Soares ‘messaged another woman’ behind his ex Faye Winter’s back after he made a shocking admission.
The former contestant, 28, who met his ex on the reality show in 2021, announced their ‘heartbreaking and difficult’ separation in February 2023 after a year-and-a-half of dating, with Faye saying they were in ‘different places.’
Speaking during his podcast, Teddy Talks, the TV personality raised eyebrows when discussing a ‘former relationship’ – although he didn’t specify who he was with.
In a discussion about boundaries, Teddy and his brother Sidney discussed how couples should make each other aware of their limits and rules in a relationship.
He recalled: ‘I remember, once upon a time, I messaged someone whilst I was in a relationship. And to me, this person was just an acquaintance.’
Furious Love Island fans have suspected Teddy Soares ‘messaged another woman’ behind his ex Faye Winter’s back after he made a shocking admission
The former contestant, 28, who met his ex on the reality show in 2021, announced their ‘heartbreaking and difficult’ separation in February 2023 after a year-and-a-half of dating (pictured in December 2022)
Teddy continued: ‘This person was just someone that I know of. We know of each other.
‘I messaged them asking about their Halloween plans. I think I might have asked this person, “Are you going to dress up as a devil or an angel? Like, what are you thinking?”
‘And I remember, the partner I was with at the time was really unhappy about this.’
Sidney questioned: ‘And why do you think your partner at the time would have been unhappy?
‘Can I jump in? I’m not your partner I can’t even imagine what being your partner would be like… but if I was on the other side of that…
‘This is what she might be thinking. ‘So, you’re thinking about what she’s wearing right now. And it could be a devil’s outfit.’
Teddy responded: ‘It was completely innocent. It was literally to find out a plan for Halloween. I don’t typically celebrate because it’s out of my comfort zone.
‘When I asked it was innocent, because let’s be real… dressing up on Halloween, you’re doing it to look a bit sexy or stand out. I’m not asking to be provocative. I was asking as in, “I’m going to steal your idea.”‘
Speaking during his podcast, Teddy Talks , the TV personality raised eyebrows when discussing a ‘former relationship’ with his brother Sidney – although he didn’t specify who
He recalled: ‘I remember, once upon a time, I messaged someone whilst I was in a relationship. And to me, this person was just an acquaintance… the partner I was with was really unhappy’
Sidney questioned: ‘Can I jump in? I’m not your partner I can’t even imagine what being your partner would be like… but if I was on the other side of that…’
Sharing their thoughts in the comment section listeners questioned: ‘Messaging a girl about her angel or devil outfit is ok in your head?’
Sidney added: ‘Whether I agree with that question or not, that doesn’t matter. You mentioned communication was key and in that moment you knew where the boundaries were in that relationship.’
‘Yeah, I have learnt from that,’ Teddy concluded.
Sharing their thoughts in the comment section listeners wrote: ‘Is teddy being fr… around 46mins in, he’s questioning whether Faye had a “genuine reason” to question why he was messaging an “attractive female” (his words) whether they’re dressing as an angel or devil (suggestive AF) but on top of that – he admits, this female is a mere ACQUAINTANCE to him?????’
‘Like bruh I maybe sympathise if she’s your genuine friend — but how can you even defend your creepy a**.. you blatantly messaged a RANDOM hot chick a suggestive message, and really thought you were gonna eat with your rationale Imao.’
‘Messaging a girl about her angel or devil outfit is ok in your head? No wonder you lost Faye… you have no idea how to treat women well. Long may you regret screwing up the best thing that happened to you.
‘You reap what you sow, if the shoe was on the other foot, your partner messaged a male friend and asked what he was wearing you can’t say you wouldn’t react the same way, are be jealous not nice message to read for anyone.’
Following his split from Faye, Teddy went on to date model Casey Boonstra, first revealing he was ‘really into her’ in October 2023.
However, just months later in January he announced he was single after calling it quits on their romance.
Making the announcement on Teddy Talks, Sidney told him: ‘You’ve transitioned into the limelight, and you get told a lot of things by people you meet. If it’s the audience commenting on romantic relationships that you choose to be in…’
Teddy jumped in and said: ‘Hey, that was plural, bro. One, one relationship.’
‘So, just to clarify, you are completely single right now?’ Sidney asked.
And Teddy confirmed: ‘Oh yeah, I’m single. Let me get that straight.’
Teddy first spoke about the relationship with Irish native Casey during an interview in October where he revealed he was dating someone new.
He told the Sun: ‘I am loved-up at the moment. Well maybe I shouldn’t say loved-up but I am seeing someone and really happy.
‘We are just taking our time and getting to know each other. I think at this stage we are just finding out about each other and becoming best friends which is really nice.’
Teddy and Casey appear to still be on good terms following the end of their relationship as they still follow each other on Instagram.
In May, Faye exclusively revealed to MailOnline Faye the real reason behind her shock split with Teddy.
Following the split Faye confessed they were both in ‘different places’ and wanted opposing things, which put a strain on their relationship (picture din Love Island in 2021)
Following his split from Faye, Teddy went on to date model Casey Boonstra (pictured), first revealing he was ‘really into her’ in October 2023. they split in January
Faye confessed they were both in ‘different places’ and wanted opposing things, which put a strain on their relationship.
She said: ‘It’s been very obvious, especially over the last few months, we just wanted different things. We were just in different places.
‘And you know, relationships… they’re hard, you know, they’re hard things to maintain. People go through breakups every single day. People go through heartbreak every single day.
‘It’s just part of life and it’s a really difficult situation to go through. I’m not ready. I don’t know if I will ever be ready to disclose what fully happened between us because that is between me and Teddy.’
