Showbiz

Andy Cohen Fires Back at Gellars RHOBH Critique

The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills executive producer Andy Cohen blasted Sarah Michelle Gellar for hating on his show while inside Radio Andy headquarters at ...

Andy Cohen Fires Back at Gellars RHOBH Critique
BN

Bintano News

March 26, 2026

Advertisement

The executive producer blasted for hating on his show while inside Radio Andy headquarters at SiriusXM Studios inside Midtown Manhattan's Rockefeller Center.

It all began March 18 when the 48-year-old Buffy the Vampire Slayer alum was asked by Page Six Radio if she was loving season 15 and she scoffed: 'No. I think it's boring.'

Co-hosts Evan Murray-Real and Danny Murphy audibly gasped at Gellar's candor, but she tried to point out her favorite parts: 'I like the cast. Like, I love Rachel [Zoe]. I think Rachel's a great addition. 

'I love [Bozoma Saint John]. I mean, I live for Kathy and Jen. Like, I want a spin-off. I want a Jen Tilly spin-off!'

'But it's slow,' the Star Search judge said. 'It's just picking up now.'

Gellar was even more savage when asked about newcomer Amanda Frances: 'I don't think she's polarizing. I just don't think anyone enjoys her.'

The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills executive producer Andy Cohen (L, pictured March 18) blasted Sarah Michelle Gellar (M) for hating on his show while inside Radio Andy headquarters at SiriusXM Studios inside Midtown Manhattan's Rockefeller Center

As soon as Cohen saw the clip, he felt betrayed because he had just interviewed the Daytime Emmy winner that same day in that same studio.

'And it was in our studio and then they post it and it's like "Sarah Michelle Gellar hates The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills" with all this Radio Andy signage everywhere,' the 57-year-old Emmy winner reacted on Andy Cohen Live.

It all began March 18 when the 48-year-old Buffy the Vampire Slayer alum was asked by Page Six Radio if she was loving season 15 and she scoffed: 'No. I think it's boring'

Advertisement

Co-hosts Evan Murray-Real (pictured) and Danny Murphy audibly gasped at Gellar's candor, but she tried to point out her favorite parts: 'I want a spin-off. I want a Jen Tilly Kathy Hilton spin-off!'

'But it's slow,' the Star Search judge said. 'It's just picking up now'

As soon as Cohen (center) saw the clip, he felt betrayed because he had just interviewed Gellar (L) that same day in that same studio

'And it was in our studio and then they post it and it's like "Sarah Michelle Gellar hates The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills" with all this Radio Andy signage everywhere,' the 57-year-old Emmy winner reacted on Andy Cohen Live 

'And I go, "You know what? Don't bring someone into my studio to trash my show. How about the door is locked when I leave? How's that? Or maybe think twice about posting that all over social media where it says 'Andy' everywhere behind SMG." She's wrong, by the way' (pictured March 15)

The Daytime Emmy winner (center) was also all smiles as Cohen (L) interviewed her on his Bravo boozy talk show Watch What Happens Live on March 17 alongside RHOBH star Dorit Kemsley (R), but it didn't air until March 20

Aside from RHOBH (pictured), the two-time Peabody Award winner also executive produces the franchises in Salt Lake City, Potomac, Orange County, Miami, London, Atlanta, Rhode Island as well as Ultimate Road Trip

Cohen will next welcome RHOBH star Kyle Richards (L) and Love Overboard host Gabby Windey (R) into the clubhouse for this Thursday's episode of Watch What Happens Live

Cohen will next welcome RHOBH star Kyle Richards and Love Overboard host Gabby Windey into the clubhouse for this Thursday's episode of Watch What Happens Live.

The Traitors reunion host will also portray a thinly-veiled version of himself in Jorma Taccone's DV murder comedy Over Your Dead Body - hitting US theaters April 24 - alongside Jason Segel, Samara Weaving, Juliette Lewis and Timothy Olyphant.

Advertisement

On the personal front, Cohen has fathered two children - son Benjamin Allen, seven, and daughter Lucy Eve, nearly four - via gestational surrogate.

The Missouri-born presenter reportedly still has two leftover frozen embryos in the 'bank' in case his children are unable to have their own and want to raise their siblings.

Advertisement