Love Island viewers were left concerned for Chloe Burrows during Sunday night’s episode as Arabella Chi revealed details of her ‘fling’ with Toby Aromolaran.
The model, 32, came face-to-face with the former footballer, 24, after entering the All Stars villa.
She revealed that the pair had ‘history’ together and that the connection between herself and Toby goes back ‘a year and a half’.
In a conversation with the girls, including Toby’s current villa partner Georgia Steel, Arabella admitted to having a connection with Toby that she had already ‘explored’ on more than one occasion.
Now some ITV2 viewers were left confused because Toby ended his relationship with Love Island star Chloe in October 2022.
Love Island viewers were left concerned for Chloe Burrows during Sunday night’s episode as Arabella Chi, (pictured) revealed details of her ‘fling’ with Toby Aromolaran
The model, 32, came face-to-face with the former footballer, 24, after entering the All Stars villa
Toby previously said he ‘couldn’t trust’ Chloe anymore after a ‘big incident’ on a night out led them to break up.
However, Arabella’s comments seemed to suggest that they had a ‘fling’ while Toby and Chloe were still in a relationship.
The stunner confirmed that she and Toby had slept together during a one night stand but later admitted she was hazy on the date it happened.
Meanwhile Toby denied that the pair had had sex when asked by the boys, unaware that Arabella had revealed all to the girls including new partner Georgia.
Taking to X one confused fan said: ‘A year and a half ago???? When did Chloe and Toby break up????’
Another wrote: ‘And when did Toby and Chloe breakup again… the timeline with Arabella is not making sense. The math just ain’t mathing right now’.
A third added: “#LoveIslandAllStars year and half has gotta be just after Chloe and Toby split since apparently they ended in October 2022. ???’
Another begged ITV2 producers to bring in Chloe: ‘SO Arabella says they slept together and Toby said they didn’t? She then said it was a year or a year and a half ago??? The stories aren’t adding up!!! Being Chloe just for the night I BEGGGG’
She revealed that the pair had ‘history’ together and that the connection between herself and Toby goes back ‘a year and a half’
The stunner confirmed that she and Toby had slept together during a one night stand but Toby denied that the pair had had sex when asked by the boys
Now some ITV2 viewers were left confused as Toby ended his relationship with Chloe in October 2022 and previously said he ‘couldn’t trust’ her anymore after a ‘big incident’ on a night out (pictured 2021)
A fourth asked: ‘Were Toby and Chloe together when he slept with Arabella or??’
Another penned: ‘Google says Toby and Chloe broke up oct 2022. Arabella says they hooked up a year and a half ago so that would be July 2022….. #LoveIslandAllStars #Loveisland’
‘Anyone realised that the timeline for Toby and Arabella seems to match up to while he was still with Chloe?’ said a sixth.
Chloe and Toby, who first met and finished as runners-up on the 2021 version of the dating reality show, confirmed their split in October 2022.
The former couple moved into a £1million Essex mansion in November 2021 and celebrated the milestone by toasting with champagne.
Their relationship was Toby’s first after he admitted before going on the show that he hadn’t been in love before.
Chloe opened up on her split from ex-boyfriend Toby in April last year, admitting it felt like the ‘saddest moment’ of her life.
In a candid chat, Chloe, 27, revealed that it was actually Toby who ended their relationship.
Arabella’s comments seemed to suggest that they had a ‘fling’ while Toby and Chloe were still in a relationship and fans were quick to point it out on X – formerly known as Twitter
Chloe and Toby, who first met and finished as runners-up on the 2021 version of the dating reality show, confirmed their split in October 2022
Speaking to fellow Love Islander, Millie Court, she said: ‘Remember when I called you crying?
‘And I was like “I don’t know what’s gonna happen, I’ve been dumped” and you were like “just live with me”.
‘And then I called you crying a few days later and you were like “I’ve booked Morocco”. I was like “wow, I love this girl”.’
Millie replied: ‘You were in a sad place and the only resolution I could think of was to go on holiday. We had a lot of fun there.’
From Love Island to living together… a look at Toby Aromolaran and Chloe Burrows’ relationship timeline
June 2021: A rocky island romance
Toby entered the Love Island villa during it’s seventh season as one of the original contestants, before Chloe later made her entrance as one of the first bombshells
Originally coupled up wit co-star Kaz Kamwi, Toby quickly had his head turned as he showed interest in Chloe – sneaking a kiss from the blonde beauty on the terrace as they began a romance.
The pair went through a rocky relationhip during the show, with his head being turned by both Abigail Rawlings and Mary Bedford, but eventually they found their way back to each other
Turbulent: The pair went through a rocky relationhip during rhe show, with his hea being turned by both Abigail Rawlings and Mary Bedford, but eventually they found their way back to each other
August 2021: Making things official
Despite the turbulent journey, Chloe and Toby turned things around to become fan favourites as they made it all the way to the final – finishing as runners up to Millie Court and Liam Reardon
But before walking away with the second place title, Toby asked Chloe to be his girlfriend with a sweet speech during their final declarations
Gushing over the blonde beauty, Toby said: ‘I’m not the best with words but for you Chlo, I’m willing to try. While I read this declaration of love with those piercing blue eyes watching me, I know that if I look up I might lose all composure! Chloe – will you be my girlfriend?’
Official: Before walking away with the second place title, Toby asked Chloe to be his girlfriend with a sweet speech during their final declarations
November 2021: Moving in together
Their romance appeared to be moving from strength to strength following Love Island, as Toby and Chloe announced that were moving in together – renting a £1million pad in Essex
At the time, a source told MailOnline: ‘This is the first time Toby has lived away from home and with a girlfriend, so it’s a big step for him and them both as a couple.
‘Cheers to us finally moving in’: Toby and Chloe announced that were moving in together in November – renting a £1million pad in Essex
April 2022: Rift rumours
The pair were hit with a wave of breakup rumours back in April, with many saying that they ‘didn’t have time for one another’ due to their conflicting work schedules
Conflict? The pair were hit with a wave of breakup rumours back in April, with many saying that they ‘didn’t have time for one another’ due to their conflicting work schedules
May 2022: First holiday together
But squashing the break-up rumour mill, they jetted off to Jamaica in May as they enjoyed their first holiday together, showing fans they were stronger than ever while sharing a slew of snaps from the getaway
Filming a short clip as they walked through the airport at Montego Bay, Chloe squealed: ‘We made it!’
Holiday time: they jetted off to Jamaica in May as they enjoyed their first holiday together
August 2022: Happy 1 year!
Chloe and Toby celebrate their one year anniversary, as the latter shares a sweet post and pens: ‘Time flies when you’re having fun! Happy 1 year anniversary’
Time flies: Chloe and Toby celebrate their one year anniversary, as the latter shares a sweet post and pens: ‘Time flies when you’re having fun! Happy 1 year anniversary’
September 2022: Birthday wishes
Toby dedicated a post to Chloe on her birthday just last month, captioning a selfie of them on holiday: ’27 years around the sun. Happy Birthday to the second pea in my pod’
27! Chloe celebrates her birthday in style with statement balloons
Pea to my pod: While Toby pens a sweet tribute to the blonde beauty
October 2022: Girls trip
Chloe jets off to Marrakesh with pal Millie for a girls’ holiday, with reports that she’s escaping relationship woes after having a tough time with Toby
‘The best friend I’ve ever had’: Chloe jetted off to Morocco last week to escape her breakup woes with former co-star Millie Court, who’s been supporting her during the tough time
October 17 2022: It’s all over as Chloe and Toby have ‘grown apart’
A source told MailOnline that Chloe and Toby, 23, are still living at their Essex home but are making arrangements to go their separate ways after a difficult few months of trying to make the relationship work.
‘Chloe and Toby put everything into their relationship – but it just hasn’t worked out between them’, a source explained.
‘There’s been no wrongdoing, they have simply grown apart, and over time realised it’s better for them both to split.
‘Naturally, Chloe has found the breakup difficult but being able to spend time abroad with Millie has given her the space she needed to start moving on.’
It’s all over: Love Island couple Chloe Burrows and Toby Aromolaran have split – 13 months after they came second on the ITV2 show
