During Friday night's instalment of the hit ITV show, couple Jack Keating, 26, and Sher Suarez, 27, were sent packing after receiving the least amount of votes.
Earlier in the episode, the villa had been transformed for a glamorous party and the Islanders were in high spirits.
But celebrations were quickly cut short when host Maya Jama made a surprise entrance with a new challenge.
She announced: 'Islanders, it’s your turn to let each other know how you really feel in tonight’s challenge To be Honest.'
Couples were asked to vote on which of their fellow Islanders best matched a series of brutally frank questions.
Love Island: All Stars' Sher and Jack have been dumped from the villa
During Friday night's instalment of the hit ITV show, couple Jack Keating, 26, and Sher Suarez, 27, were sent packing after receiving the least amount of votes
Kicking things off, Maya asked: 'Which couple do you find most boring?'
Jack and Sher chose Jessy Potts and Tommy Bradley, with Jack explaining: 'It’s early days you haven’t had any drama…'
Belle Hassan once again shared her thoughts on Sean and Lucinda’s relationship before Maya cut in: 'Alright… let’s move it on.'
Islanders were then asked which couple were 'staying together until something better comes along'.
Helena Ford and Carrington Rodriguez voted for Belle and Harrison Solomon, with Helena making a cheeky swipe: 'More Harrison than Belle… Belle’s a bit too good for Harrison.'
However, the drama didn't end with the challenge.
After revealing the winners, Maya announced that the couple with the fewest votes from the public would be leaving the villa - and Jack and Sher found themselves in the firing line.
Elsewhere in the episode, Love Island: All Stars viewers branded Belle and Helena 'beggy and embarrassing' after they stormed into the secret garden in a bid to stop their partners from speaking to other girls.
Earlier in the episode, the villa had been transformed for a glamorous party and the Islanders were in high spirits
But celebrations were quickly cut short when host Maya Jama made a surprise entrance with a new challenge
Couples were asked to vote on which of their fellow Islanders best matched a series of brutally frank questions. However, the drama didn't end with the challenge
After revealing the winners, Maya announced that the couple with the fewest votes from the public would be leaving the villa - and Jack and Sher found themselves in the firing line
At the beginning of the episode, Harrison, 23, and Carrington, 28, pulled bombshell Jessy, 27, and Sher for a chat in the villa's secret garden.
But the conversation was cut short when Helena, 29, and Belle, 27, burst in moments later, grinning as they interrupted their chat.
Fans quickly flocked to X, formerly Twitter, to blast the pair, branding them 'beggy' and insisting the boys should be allowed to explore other connections in the villa.
One wrote: 'belle and helena walking into the secret garden while they’re talking is EMBARRASSING a**… like they think it’s a bad b****h move like nah it’s a BEGGY move #LoveIsland #LoveIslandAllStars.'
'This is so beggy of Belle and Helena.'; 'Belle and Helena look stupid imo. it ain't that deep.';
'Belle & Helena are so embarrassing.'; 'Helena and Belle are weak, everyone had their chats on the secret garden and no one barged in on them.'
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
A new start and what better place than home? Back to the Villa! A fresh start in the place that started it all.
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I felt really grateful to experience the Villa over four years ago - why would I not want to experience it again?
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I feel like I'm ready to find me a husband! I'm sick of heartbreak and I'm ready to meet someone new
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
Apart from the last week in the Villa, I loved my time on Love Island. I want to do it again as it can only get better.
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
Even though I ended up winning the series with Sammy, I felt like I had a bit of a rocky ride the first time and I feel like I've matured a lot more since.
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I want to be open in the way that I should have been in Series 6 and the streets are the trenches, so this is the only way to find someone!
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
Since my time on Love Island 10, I think I've been on a journey for the last two and half years and I've always had in my head that All Stars is the final chapter of that journey.
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I've been single a while so I'm really excited to go in and hopefully find a romantic connection with someone.
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I want to find real love, that would be amazing… I had love during my time on Love Island Australia, and it was really nice!
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
Honestly, I felt that my time in the Love Island USA villa was cut short, I didn’t get the best shot at getting to know someone so for me, experiencing Love Island again but in the UK is perfect. I’ve always travelled the world and I love meeting girls outside of the US.
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I don’t know anyone in the UK! Best case scenario, I get a British girlfriend, worst case, I have a lot of friends in a new country - and that’s a blessing. The UK isn’t far from LA. That’s a direct flight!
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
From first hand experience, I know that Love Island works. I know the Love Island Gods can bring me love as I did find love the first time in the US. I love a good accent. Everyone there is my type!
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I feel like I didn’t handle certain situations in there very well and I feel like, even though it’s only been seven or eight months since the show, I’ve done a lot of growing up and self reflection.
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
To find love! I've been single for just over a year now, I'm ready to settle down again.
Nas will be entering the villa almost a year after splitting from girlfriend Eva Zapico four years after they met in the villa
JACK KEATING
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I have to come back and redeem myself, my experience before was short & sweet. Revenge tour is here!
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I like the fact that you can find someone from a different area and lifestyle - that's quite exciting
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
It was the best time of my life. I was so out of my comfort zone but learnt so much about myself and met friends for life. I want a second chance at meeting someone romantically
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I'd like a fair crack at the whip! The first time round, I was in there for five days and I really want to find someone
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
Last time I did find love but it didn't work out. This time round, I need to find a wife and give my mum some grandchildren!
SERIES 9 LOVE ISLAND AND ALL STARS SERIES 2
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I feel like my last time in the All Stars Villa, I didn't get a fair shot and it's such an amazing experience so if I can do it one more time, why not?
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
It's another opportunity to find somebody; I didn't find a girl the first time round so it's a great chance to try again.
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
Last series I left with Ekin-Su but that didn’t quite go to plan, I’m still getting older so hopefully I can find some love, or at least start another journey to find love.
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I’m lonely these days. It would be nice to meet somebody in there. I want to have somebody to really date. I really want that. I’m not just going in to mess around. I’m going to put my best foot forward.
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I fully believe my husband has to be British. I’ve been trying to date in America for so long and I’ve given up. This time around it’ll be different. I’ve grown up, I’ll make better choices.
Why do you want to return to Love Island?
I’m so excited to go back into the world of Love Island, to show my growth and look for someone who is serious.
Why do you want to come back to Love Island?
I’m still single! I need to meet someone and settle down, my parents are asking for grandkids! I met someone last time, it didn’t work out, but it’s a nice environment to meet someone.