Viewers Claim Liberty Brutally Pies Mitch on Love Island All Stars Before Criticizing His Emotional Maturity in Snog Marry Pie, Sparking Calls for Her to Move On

Mitchel Taylor was brutally pied by Liberty Poole in Monday’s episode of Love Island All Stars.

The gang played the classic game Snog Marry Pie where she picked to slap him with cream and cake after he ditched her in previous scenes.

After the pie she told him he had the ’emotional maturity of a two-year old’ in a scathing rant as he hit back at her.

After the game many viewers took to Twitter to says she now needed to let things go after they have gone back and forth since the start of the series.

She cried over him again on the episode after he told her he wanted to crack on with Georgia Harrison instead.

Mitch Taylor was brutally pied by Liberty Poole in Monday's episode of Love Island All Stars on ITV

Mitch Taylor was brutally pied by Liberty Poole in Monday’s episode of Love Island All Stars on ITV

The gang played the classic game Snog Marry Pie where she picked to slap him with cream and cake after he ditched her in previous scenes

The gang played the classic game Snog Marry Pie where she picked to slap him with cream and cake after he ditched her in previous scenes

One said after Snog Marry Pie: ‘Okay I get Mitch is messy but WHYYYYY is Liberty acting like a wife who was left at the altar? She was with him for about 7 minutes and she’s behaving like it was 7 years #LoveIsland #loveislandallstars.’

Another said: ‘Unpopular opinion but what Mitch done to Liberty isn’t even half as bad as what Georgia S has done #Loveisland #loveislandallstars.’

A third penned: ‘I’m not Mitchell’s biggest fan but surely the way Liberty has been acting over this situation is a bit far fetched, she’s acting like they were coupled up for weeks before and I’m sure Mitch called it off a few days ago.’

Another said: ‘I love Liberty but I need her to let this one go. I get she didn’t want to be mugged off after what happened to her before but her and Mitch weren’t that deep. She needs to learn to pick her battles. #loveisland.’

Earlier in the episode Love Island All Stars fans slammed Liberty for crying over Mitchel again during Monday’s episode of the show.

The pair have had a rocky relationship since they were first coupled-up early on in the series.

Liberty, 24, was first paired by the public with her ex Jake Cornish but, after he left the show, she explored her connection with former gas engineer Mitch, 27.

After the pie she told him he had the 'emotional maturity of a two-year old' in a scathing rant as he hit back at her

After the pie she told him he had the ’emotional maturity of a two-year old’ in a scathing rant as he hit back at her

After the game many viewers took to Twitter to says she now needed to let things go after they have gone back and forth since the start of the series (seen with Kaz in the game)

After the game many viewers took to Twitter to says she now needed to let things go after they have gone back and forth since the start of the series (seen with Kaz in the game)

80608099 13020963 image a 206 1706567348760

80608101 13020963 image a 210 1706567366007

80608095 13020963 image a 209 1706567362600

80608093 13020963 image a 208 1706567357418

One said after Snog Marry Pie: 'Okay I get Mitch is messy but WHYYYYY is Liberty acting like a wife who was left at the altar?

One said after Snog Marry Pie: ‘Okay I get Mitch is messy but WHYYYYY is Liberty acting like a wife who was left at the altar?

While they first appeared to be getting on well, it seemed Mitchel had different ideas as he told her he was open to getting to know the other female Islanders, leaving her in tears.

This week she was left sobbing again after chatting to him about how they felt about one another despite officially ending things last week as he planned to pursue a connection with Georgia Harrison.

Liberty told him: ‘I think I deserve better. Obviously I hope all the best for you and Georgia. We’ll be friends.’

She then gave him a hug before quickly turning on her heels and saying ‘see you later’ before walking off.

Lib was later seen shedding a tear as she recounted the conversation to her fellow Islanders, prompting viewers to take to social media to implore her to stop crying over Mitchel.

One person wrote on Twitter: ‘I’m sorry but I’m tired of Liberty crying.’

While someone else shared: ‘Not liberty still crying over Mitch.’

Another person noted: ‘5 minutes in and Liberty is crying already,’ while someone else asked: ‘Why is Liberty crying, they broke up like 10 times.’

One other viewer asked: ‘How many times will Liberty have this convo and cry over Mitch? Hang it up babe.’

Someone else exclaimed: ‘Liberty finally let go of Messy Mitch!’

While another person wrote: ‘Oh come on Liberty always knew Mitch was not into her, not his biggest fan but he always said he was open.’ 

It comes after Love Island viewers were left fuming with Mitchel as he dumped partner Liberty just hours after choosing her in the recoupling during Friday’s episode.

The former gas engineer was seen pulling Liberty for a chat, insisting he’d been ‘transparent with her and that he’d told Liberty he wanted to be open to chatting to other girls throughout.

Mitch said: ‘I’m fed up of being stressed,’ which which Liberty said: ‘It’s fine, we’ll just be friends.’

She then went over and told Kaz: ‘We’ve just decided to be friends because it’s not healthy to have this many arguments and we don’t know if it’s even salvageable at this point because of everything that’s gone on us.

‘It’s sad though because I do feel like we had something special.’

The moment left viewers unimpressed, with one person writing on Twitter: ‘HOW DARE MITCH SAY THAT. It’s his actions that upset Liberty!!! Then twisting it and blaming liberty for the reason why girls don’t talk to him. What a p**ck.’

Another person posted: ‘How is Mitch convincing Liberty that she caused all these arguments? GET HIM OUT. DRAFT HIM IN WW3.’

While someone else shared: ‘Why is Mitch moving like Liberty was the one causing stress?? Is he alright??’

‘Nah not Mitch blaming Liberty for other girls not getting to know him. Wow I can’t believe,’ wrote another viewer, while someone else posted: ‘The way he made Lib feel like she made the decision to end it.’

Someone else wrote: ‘Mitch says that he doesn’t know what he wants and that no girl wants to talk to him because of how upset Liberty has been. It is interesting because if no girl wants to talk to him, then why his in the villa? Just causing drama all the time will get boring.’

Love Island: All Stars turns nasty on Monday night, when the beloved game of Snog, Marry, Pie returns to screens to viewers' delight

Love Island: All Stars turns nasty on Monday night, when the beloved game of Snog, Marry, Pie returns to screens to viewers’ delight

One of the biggest conflicts on the show has undoubtedly been that of exes Molly Smith and Callum Jones, which came to a head last week when he admitted that he had slept with 16 women since they broke up six months ago

One of the biggest conflicts on the show has undoubtedly been that of exes Molly Smith and Callum Jones, which came to a head last week when he admitted that he had slept with 16 women since they broke up six months ago 

Georgia S meanwhile only deepens her love triangle with Tom Clare and Callum, having stunned fans by juggling the pair in recent days

Georgia S meanwhile only deepens her love triangle with Tom Clare and Callum, having stunned fans by juggling the pair in recent days

And another show fan posted: ‘How can Mitch go from saying he doesn’t wanna get to know anyone else to saying he’s not sure if he even likes Liberty??? to than friend zoning her.’

Another viewer shared: ‘Pob eared Mitch looking down on Liberty believing he is too good for ….mental.’

While someone else wrote: ‘Liberty you’re better off without Mitch girl it’s a blessing.’

Aside from Liberty and Mitchel, Friday’s recouping saw Hannah couple-up with Tyler, Callum choose Georgia S, Toby pair up with Arabella, Anton match with Georgia H and Chris choose to couple up with Kaz.

Love Island All Stars continues on Tuesday 30 January at 9pm on ITV2 and ITVX. 

LOVE ISLAND ALL STARS: MEET THE CAST

Liberty Poole

79745789 12936149 image m 94 1704715687418

AGE: 24

SERIES: 7 

Why are you returning to the Love Island Villa? I’m a lot more confident in who I am and sure about exactly what I want from a relationship. I just want to have fun and meet a lovely boy.

How will you feel if you come across an ex in the Villa or someone you’ve dated from the show since appearing? It’s always going to be awkward isn’t it, it’s always going to be weird seeing someone that you’ve been with getting with someone else. I wish my exes nothing but the best. I’m going to be focused on my own journey.

Kaz Kamwi

79738979 12936149 image a 6 1706111510004

AGE: 29

SERIES: 7

Why are you returning to the Love Island Villa? To be totally honest, I actually really want to find love. 

I had a great time last series but I want to have an even better time.

How will you feel if you come across an ex in the Villa or someone you’ve previously dated from the show? The thing is, I’m a bad b*tch so I will handle it with as much grace as I can.

 

Georgia Harrison

79737905 12936149 image a 2 1706111509537

AGE: 29 

SERIES: 3

Why are you returning to the Love Island Villa? This is the last year of my 20s so I want to go in the Villa and have some fun and hopefully meet someone that I can fall in love with. I’m lucky in the sense that I’ve got everything in my life that I could possibly wish for, apart from love.

If you had to pick your top Islanders from Series 1 to 10 to couple up with who would they be and why? Chris Taylor, he’s hilarious and the main thing I’m attracted to is a man who can make me laugh. What a fun guy and like I said, I’m looking for someone to TikTok with so I reckon he’d be game for that sort of stuff!

Hannah Elizabeth

79742337 12936149 image a 7 1706111510122

AGE: 33

SERIES: 1

Why are you returning to the Love Island Villa? I’m returning to the Love Island Villa because I did it eight years ago and what an opportunity I never thought I’d get again. I’m not very good at finding love but I had a ball the first time, so I’m going to have a ball again.

You got engaged on the show last time, do you think wedding bells could be on the cards again this time round? Absolutely not, not in the Villa no. Maybe when I get out, but I’d need to give it a bit of time.

 

Georgia Steel

79740543 12936149 image a 8 1706111510123

AGE: 25

SERIES: 4

Why are you returning to the Love Island Villa? I’m 25, I have a house, a cat, a nice car – I have everything in life but a boyfriend, so why not give it as go.

You’ve been brave and honest in opening up about being conned by a former partner. How has this experience impacted the way in which you now approach dating? 

I take that experience as a really positive reflection now. I look at it as something I had to go through to make me stronger and learn things in life for me to be able to learn what I want in my next partner.

Molly Smith  

80131949 12936149 image a 1 1706111509528

AGE: 29

SERIES: 6 

What do you need to know? Molly entered her season as a Casa Amor bombshell and managed to turn Callum Jones’ head.  

It’s believed she ended things with Callum after three years because she ‘wanted to get engaged’ but the offer was seemingly not forthcoming. 

Arabella Chi

80299655 12936149 image a 5 1706111510003

AGE: 32

SERIES: 5 

What do you need to know? Despite a fleeting stint on her series she has hit the headlines with a series of high profile romances since, most recently with footballer Ruben Dias. 

She was linked to former French rugby player Yoann Huget and  DJ Tom Zanetti. She also enjoyed a brief dalliance with fellow All Star Toby Aromolaran.

 Tom Clare

80415621 12936149 image m 17 1706111578475

AGE: 24

SERIES: 9

Why are you returning to the Villa?

I found love last time, so I am back and ready to give it another go.

What will you do differently this time round?

Last time I did exactly what I wanted and got the girl that I wanted, so no I wouldn’t do anything different.

Why do you think the Villa is the perfect place to find love?

When you’re with someone 24/7 you really get to know them. It can be such an alien environment, so you really get to know someone in a short space of time. It’s Love Island – it’s the best place!

 

Toby Aromolaran

79738419 12936149 image a 9 1706111510127

AGE: 24

SERIES: 7

Why are you returning to the Love Island Villa? If I’m Single and Love Island is an opportunity for me, how could you turn down the chance to find love again?!

You were in a long term relationship with Chloe Burrows, what do you think her reaction will be when she hears you are going into the Villa? I don’t know how she would take it. We will always have love for each other and I think she would wish me the best of luck, as I would certainly do the same.

 

Chris Taylor 

79740063 12936149 image a 15 1706111510273

AGE: 33

SERIES: 5

Why are you returning to the Love Island Villa? Last time I was only there for 15 days, so I want to do it and enjoy it all again. I am 33 now and getting on a bit – I am getting ear hair! It would be nice to have a girl to keep my ears trimmed for me!

How did the Barbie Movie come about? I was invited to an afterparty by Margot Robbie and then ended up at an after party with her. I started to panic and make conversation with her, just having really stupid chats. All I can assume is that my silly chat made an impression on Margot Robbie. 18 months later I got an email from Warner Brothers. 

 

Anton Danyluk

79741257 12936149 image a 11 1706111510131

AGE: 29

SERIES: 5

Why are you returning to the Love Island Villa? For me it was a no brainer. I got the call and it’s a once in a lifetime opportunity and probably the best summer I have ever had in my life. Getting the chance to do it twice is going to be unbelievable.

Why do you think the Love Island Villa is the perfect place to find love? 

I think this time with Love Island: All Stars, things will be different, as we all understand what it’s like to go on Love Island and the only thing now missing is finding a partner.

 

Mitchel Taylor

79749447 12936149 image a 3 1706111509538

AGE: 27

SERIES: 10 

Why are you returning to the Love Island villa? I think I went in with my heart on my sleeve the first time and got hurt and this time I am just going in to enjoy myself and if a connection happens, a connection happens.

In the summer you were given the name ‘Messy Mitch’, and a name that you have taken on as your own,  can we expect more of the same in the series? I’ll be honest, I don’t really plan on being ‘Messy Mitch’. It just depends on what day of the week it is. I wear my emotions on my sleeve and what you see is what you get. I am very honest and very opinionated and I think that’s what people like me for.

Callum Jones 

80131951 12936149 image a 4 1706111509762

AGE: 27

SERIES: 6 

What do you need to know? Callum caused shockwaves in his series when he ended his romance with Shauna Phillips and recoupled with Molly Smith in Casa Amor.

The couple went on to have a three-year relationship, even moving in together in Manchester but split last year, months before an awkward reunion in the Love Island All Stars villa. 

Josh Ritchie 

80299653 12936149 image a 14 1706111510225

AGE: 29

SERIES: 1 

What do you need to know? Joshua, was one of the original Islanders in 2015 and has since made a name for himself on reality TV shows including Ex on the Beach and Celebs Go Dating – and because of his highly publicised romances.

He dated fellow All Stars contestant Georgia Harrison as well as Geordie Shore star Charlotte Crosby. 

Tyler Cruickshank

80367217 12936149 image a 10 1706111510129

AGE: 28 

SERIES: 7

What do you need to know? Tyler made it to the final of his season with Kaz Kamwi despite a rocky moment when his head was turned in Casa Amor. 

While they were able to rekindle their romance ultimately Tyler split from Kaz just three months after leaving the villa, blaming the ‘adjustment to being in the public eye’ as the reason for the break up. 

Sophie Piper

80415623 12936149 image m 19 1706111590829

AGE: 24

SERIES: 6 

Why are you returning to the famous Love Island Villa?

I had a fun experience the first time around but I didn’t go the full way and find love, so I’d love to find someone this time.

What will you do differently this time round?

I’m quite chilled and don’t want drama, so I think I will approach this time round in a similar way. I’m a one guy kind of girl.

Why do you think the Villa is the perfect place to find love?

It’s a once in a lifetime experience and not something that comes up every day. 

 

Previous Article

Shannon Beador and Alexis Bellino Coincidentally Arrive at the Same Time to Film RHOC following Shannon's Statement of Being Hurt by Alexis Dating Her Ex, John Janssen

Next Article

Chris Pine flaunts his distinctive and eccentric fashion in a colorful striped cardigan and shorts during a coffee outing in Los Angeles.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Subscribe to our email newsletter to get the latest posts delivered right to your email.
Pure inspiration, zero spam ✨