J-Lo Stunned by Alex Rodriguez ‘Side Chick’ Rumors Impact on Engagement

Jennifer Lopez remained silent in 2021 when her then-fiancé Alex Rodriguez was alleged to be chatting up Southern Charm star Madison LeCroy, but she was confronted point blank over the rumor on Wednesday.

Watch What Happens Live host Andy Cohen gingerly asked the 56-year-old pop diva if it was true that ‘A-Rod was DMing one of the cast members’ during her fifth time being grilled for Plead the Fifth.

Jennifer furrowed her brow in comprehension and then began rubbing her hands together in a sign of self-soothing and said, ‘Okay.’

‘There was a lot of speculation in the press or on this show that that somehow led to your breakup. Is there anything you can speak to about that?’ the 57-year-old presenter asked.

‘You know, I really have nothing to say about my personal life anymore,’ Jennifer shockingly declared.

‘I feel like it’s… I’m done with that.’

Jennifer Lopez remained silent in 2021 when her then-fiancé Alex Rodriguez was alleged to be chatting up Southern Charm star Madison LeCroy, but she was confronted point blank over the rumor on Wednesday

Watch What Happens Live host Andy Cohen gingerly asked the 56-year-old pop diva if it was true that ‘A-Rod was DMing one of the cast members’ during her fifth time being grilled for Plead the Fifth

At that the clubhouse crowd began applauding and Lopez, appearing relieved, exclaimed: ‘Yes! Support! Support!’

The two-time Grammy nominee and the 50-year-old Minnesota Timberwolves co-owner famously ended their four-year relationship in April 2021 shortly after posing for their final selfie on March 26, 2021.

However, Jennifer and her now fourth ex-husband Ben Affleck reportedly started surreptitiously texting each other again in February 2021 before tying the knot in 2022 and finalizing their divorce on February 21.

Madison first hinted about ‘DMing’ with an ‘ex-MLB player’ during the seventh season Southern Charm reunion special that aired in January 2021 but noted that she had ‘never seen him [or] touched him.’

In 2023, the 35-year-old Bravo-lebrity told the Pillows and Beer podcast that Alex would frequently FaceTime her and offered to fly her to Miami multiple times.

‘I told [Rodriguez], I said, “If you’re looking for a side chick,” which clearly he was, “it wasn’t gonna be me.” I’m wifey material,’ LeCroy – who wed Brett Randle in 2022 – scoffed.

At the time, the retired New York Yankee spokesman told Page Six: ‘Her 15 minutes of fame are up, and she is trying get a 16th minute. Please stop wasting everyone’s time with these false narratives. They were false two years ago and continue to be false.’

Jennifer furrowed her brow in comprehension and then began rubbing her hands together in a sign of self-soothing and said, ‘Okay’

‘There was a lot of speculation in the press or on this show that that somehow led to your breakup. Is there anything you can speak to about that?’ the 57-year-old presenter asked

‘You know, I really have nothing to say about my personal life anymore,’ Jennifer shockingly declared. ‘I feel like it’s… I’m done with that’

At that the clubhouse crowd began applauding and Lopez, appearing relieved, exclaimed: ‘Yes! Support! Support!’

The two-time Grammy nominee and the 50-year-old Minnesota Timberwolves co-owner famously ended their four-year relationship in April 2021 shortly after posing for their final selfie on March 26, 2021 (pictured) 

However, Jennifer and her now fourth ex-husband Ben Affleck (L, pictured in 2024) reportedly started surreptitiously texting each other again in February 2021 before tying the knot in 2022 and finalizing their divorce on February 21

Madison first hinted about ‘DMing’ with an ‘ex-MLB player’ during the seventh season Southern Charm reunion special that aired in January 2021 but noted that she had ‘never seen him [or] touched him’

In 2023, the 35-year-old Bravo-lebrity told the Pillows and Beer podcast that Alex would frequently FaceTime her and offered to fly her to Miami multiple times